On top of the rules differences between the pro and college football game, there are a variety of game management differences that make both distinct. College football has always been a great area for experimentation for offensive, defensive, and special teams tactics. Three particular strategies remain popular in the college football game and have not translated successfully to the NFL, for various reasons.
One such tactic, and one used by a majority of college football teams in some form, is the option run. The option run has been a staple of college football for its entire history, allowing quarterbacks and running backs to improvise a play based on the actions of defensive players. The option run, in essence, allows the quarterback to fake to the fullback on a run up the middle, a pitch to the halfback to the outside, or a quarterback keeper around end. This triple option has slowly died out as it has given way to the double option and the flexbone offense of schools like Air Force. The double option is a simple sweep to the outside, where a quarterback can decide to keep it for himself or pitch to the halfback. The flexbone offense requires a variety of movements and fake pitches to create confusion amongst defensive players. The reason why this scheme doesn’t work in the professional game is that coaches don’t want to put higher priced quarterbacks in the position to get hit on every play.
Another scheme that is often used in the modern college football game is the spread offense. While the spread offense is a more general term for an offense that passes often, it can encompass a variety of formations. A quarterback is typically set back in the shotgun in the spread, with at least four receivers out in patterns to give him more options in the passing game. As well, the spread offense features some elements of option runs, with fake reverses and hand offs not out of the question. While a couple of different NFL teams have used elements of the spread offense, including the Houston Oilers and Detroit Lions of the early 1990’s, the skill and speed of NFL defensive players typically dictates that offense be more balanced and traditional. The spread offense leaves the quarterback open to a defensive blitz, and more mistakes can be made in the passing game with more passing attempts.
A final trend in game management that has been successfully used in college football is more aggressive special teams plays. Whether it is a clever fake field goal or punt or an aggressive punt block play, college football features more interesting special teams scenarios in one weekend than a whole season of professional football. The reason why college teams do these plays is that the average college roster features more than one hundred players while the NFL roster limit is 53 players. With so many more players at their disposal, college coaches can find niche players that are good at breaking through blocks to get to a punter or a kicker who can pass the ball on fake field goals. As well, the types of players that play on special teams in college football are not as well rounded as those in the NFL. Special teams players in college typically are low on the depth chart at other positions, meaning that they haven’t had the practice or game experience necessary to give a consistent performance. In the NFL, special teams players often play at other positions, with some even starting on the offensive or defensive lines. In this way, the performance in blocking and protecting kickers and punters is much higher in the NFL than in college.