Live At The Apollo Volume II Idaho

Live At The Apollo Volume II

James Brown

Polydor, 1968

REVIEW BY: Sean McCarthy

ORIGINALLY PUBLISHED: 12/27/2006

You won’t get a good indication of the seismic shifts in American culture by listening to Live At The Apollo Volume II. However, the general chaos of 1968 can be heard here; for one thing, instead of the tight, under-35-minutes perfection of Live At The Apollo, 1968’s Volume II surpasses 70 minutes.

And while 1963’s Live At The Apollo may be perfection, Volume II, as the advertising says in the liner notes replica of the album cover, is “Two Big Albums In One.” “It’s A Man’s Man’s World” clocks in at just under 20 minutes. “I Got You (I Feel Good)” zips in at under 20 seconds before “Please, Please, Please” comes in. Hyper-sexy jams “Cold Sweat” and “Let Yourself Go” are like odd couple neighbors to melodramatic and conservative covers of “That’s Life” and “I Wanna Be Around.” In other words, Volume II is a mess, but what a beautiful mess it is.

Even with the too-lengthy jams and slightly corny rendition of “That’s Life,” James Brown’s band somehow makes it come together. The reason, of course, was James Brown’s relentless perfectionism. The “stop and go” movements of “Let Yourself Go” and “Try Me” are a marvel to hear in their studio forms, but played live, they take on another form entirely.

The inclusion of audience noise in live albums is usually an excuse for self-indulgence. And sometimes the audience noise in Volume II makes it difficult to appreciate the musicianship of Brown’s band. But the screams and shrieks are essential to the live album experience of both Volume I and II because it showcases how James Brown was able to utterly work an audience into a frenzy. In “It’s A Man’s Man’s World,” Brown uses lengthy pauses to slowly build a mood, then he lets out one of his trademark screams as a climactic release.