New 802.11n Routers: The Best Wi-Fi Yet Wisconsin

The best new 802.11n wireless routers deliver strong performance, coverage, and compatibility--but picking the right one for your network is more complicated than ever. Our lab tests reveal the top choices, whether you are looking for a basic bargain or consider speed and range paramount.


1. Local Companies

Tds Telecom Paging
(715) 748-7178
202 Ogden St
Medford, WI
Tds Telecom Paging
(715) 748-7115
202 Ogden St
Medford, WI
Tds Telecom
(608) 849-4124
Waunakee, WI
Tds Telecom Paging
(715) 748-7168
202 Ogden St
Medford, WI
Tds Telecom Paging
(715) 748-7127
202 Ogden St
Medford, WI
Tds Telecom
(608) 849-4124
Waunakee, WI
Tds Telecom
(608) 568-3801
Dickeyville, WI
Northcentral Telcom
(414) 445-1167
3281 N 41st St
Milwaukee, WI
Tds Telecom Paging
(715) 748-7116
202 Ogden St
Medford, WI
MCI Telecommunications
(715) 835-1600
Madison, WI


2. Introduction

Illustration by Mick Wiggins.What a difference a couple of years makes. In our first roundup of draft-802.11n Wi-Fi routers (see "Wireless Routers: The Truth About Superfast Draft-N"), we found so many problems, we couldn't recommend any of them: Firmware was buggy, interoperability between vendors was hit-and-miss, and performance was not as good as that of some enhanced, earlier-generation 802.11g routers.

As of this year, we're happy to report, those issues have largely gone away. Although the standard is still technically in draft form and final ratification of 802.11n by the IEEE isn't expected until next year, the Wi-Fi Alliance has been certifying draft-2.0 n routers for interoperability and compatibility since last year, and the final version should largely be a formality that at most may require a firmware upgrade.

And the Wi-Fi certified products are worthy updates. With link rates--the nominal connection speeds, as opposed to real-world throughput--of up to 300 megabits per second (compared with 54 mbps for standard 802.11g) and extended range (thanks to multiple smart antennas), 802.11n Wi-Fi is the first Wi-Fi technology that can rival wired 100-mbps ethernet in performance. Upgrading your home router to 802.11n is thus one of the quickest and easiest ways to improve your network.

But choosing a particular 802.11n router has become more complicated than ever because the standard covers a lot of ground that lets vendors issue a dizzying array of product options, with literally dozens of models ranging in price from $50 to $250. D-Link alone has six 802.11n routers.

To give an idea of the options, we chose two widely available models in each of three categories: under-$90 routers for people who don't need maximum performance, but who can nonetheless benefit from 802.11n's improved range and speed; midrange (about $150) models that offer top wireless speeds and gigabit ethernet; and dual-band routers ($180 to $200) that support both the crowded 2.4-GHz frequency range (used by all of the less-Expensive models and their 802.11b/g predecessors) and the relatively open 5-GHz band, with support for legacy 802.11a gear. These top-of-the-line units target users preparing for an expected influx of networked multimedia devices that need uncluttered bandwidth to stream media. (The 802.11n spec supports both frequencies.) Up to now, vendors have been focusing on the 2.4-GHz band in order to support the vast majority of legacy devices.

For a point-by-point comparison of the six routers we examined, see our chart, "Wi-Fi Draft-2.0 802.11N Routers: Good, Better, and Best."

3. Deconstructing the Technology

The 802.11n variant of Wi-Fi achieves its high through­put (typically four times that of 802.11g) in two ways. First, it uses MIMO (multiple input, multiple output) antenna technology to transmit more data at a time. Intelligent antennas combine streams of data arriving at different times from multi­path signals bouncing off walls, floors, and ceilings. Entry-level routers typically have two receiving and transmitting antennas; midrange and high-end models have three of each.

Second, draft-n uses channel bonding: Instead of the 20-MHz-wide channels found in previous Wi-Fi standards, 802.11n can use 40-MHz-wide channels, which in theory should double their data-carrying capacity.

Unfortunately, the limited bandwidth of the 2.4-GHz range means that just one 802.11n router using channel bonding will take up virtually the entire 2.4-GHz spectrum, leaving no room for neighboring routers, and causing severe interference. For this reason, draft-2.0's so-called good-neighbor policies require that routers ship in 20-MHz mode, and that, when in 40-MHz mode, they drop to 20-MHz operation if they sense nearby Wi-Fi nets or other 2.4-GHz devices. The top link rate in 20-MHz mode is only 150 mbps (rather than the much-advertised 300 mbps); since many users are likely to be within range of other 2.4-GHz traffic, we ran our 2.4-GHz tests with 20-MHz channels.

4. More Bandwidth, Less Range

The 5-GHz frequency range, however, has much more bandwidth to play with and can support multiple 40-MHz channels. It's also relatively unused (802.11a products appeared primarily in business environments), so interference is generally minimal to none. We therefore used 40-MHz channels in our 5-GHz testing of the two routers that support 5-GHz operations.

Interestingly, even with twice as much channel bandwidth, speeds in our 5-GHz testing at close range did not double; on average, they rose about 20 percent. But they were generally more consistent than the 2.4-GHz results, and throughput at close range never dropped below 40 mbps--well above the 25 mbps needed for top-quality HDTV streaming.

The downside to 5-GHz: Its higher frequency doesn't allow it to cover as large an area as 2.4-GHz draft-n. But its range is still generally far better than that of standard unenhanced 802.11g.

Another 5-GHz plus: While draft-n is backward-compatible with 802.11b and g gear in "mixed" 2.4-GHz mode, performance for n clients drops significantly on networks when b or g clients are present. But with a dual-band router, you can put newer draft-n gear that supports 5 GHz on the fast track while maintaining a slower 2.4-GHz network for older gear. We recommend a dual-band router if you need maximum performance for streaming media or networked storage--or if you can't get a good Wi-Fi signal at all due to interference from neighbors' networks.

Draft-N on a Budget

Bare bones n: D-Link's $80 Wireless-N Router DIR-615 (left) and Belkin's $90 N Wireless Router have only two transmitting and receiving antennas each, making them slower than pricier models.D-Link and Belkin routers; click for enlarged image.Want to have some of draft-n's superior speed and coverage without paying top dollar? We tried two entry-level draft-2.0-certified routers priced at $90 or less: the Belkin N Wireless Router ($90) and the D-Link Wireless N DIR-615 ($80). These products have 100-mbps (not gigabit) ethernet ports and two-antenna configurations with less speed and range than their three-eared cousins. While not optimal for streaming media, they should be fine for normal Internet use, VoIP calls, and the odd file transfer in a small-to-medium-size house.

Of the two, the Belkin was generally superior. The D-Link has a few features the Belkin lacks, but it stumbled badly in our performance tests.

5. Featured National Company

Millennium Information Technolgies

678-297-9823
1885 McFarland Road
Alpharetta, GA
www.minfotech.com

We are an Asset Recovery Company. We specialized in Buying and Selling used and refurbished technology hardware. Everything from used IBM, to Used Cisco, to Used Symbol and everything in between. Check us out Today!

Regional Articles
- New 802.11n Routers: The Best Wi-Fi Yet Appleton WI
- New 802.11n Routers: The Best Wi-Fi Yet Baraboo WI
- New 802.11n Routers: The Best Wi-Fi Yet Beaver Dam WI
- New 802.11n Routers: The Best Wi-Fi Yet Beloit WI
- New 802.11n Routers: The Best Wi-Fi Yet Brookfield WI
- New 802.11n Routers: The Best Wi-Fi Yet Burlington WI
- New 802.11n Routers: The Best Wi-Fi Yet Cedarburg WI
- New 802.11n Routers: The Best Wi-Fi Yet Chippewa Falls WI
- New 802.11n Routers: The Best Wi-Fi Yet Cudahy WI
- New 802.11n Routers: The Best Wi-Fi Yet De Pere WI
- New 802.11n Routers: The Best Wi-Fi Yet Delavan WI
- New 802.11n Routers: The Best Wi-Fi Yet Eau Claire WI
- New 802.11n Routers: The Best Wi-Fi Yet Elkhorn WI
- New 802.11n Routers: The Best Wi-Fi Yet Fond Du Lac WI
- New 802.11n Routers: The Best Wi-Fi Yet Fort Atkinson WI
- New 802.11n Routers: The Best Wi-Fi Yet Franklin WI
- New 802.11n Routers: The Best Wi-Fi Yet Germantown WI
- New 802.11n Routers: The Best Wi-Fi Yet Grafton WI
- New 802.11n Routers: The Best Wi-Fi Yet Green Bay WI
- New 802.11n Routers: The Best Wi-Fi Yet Hartford WI
- New 802.11n Routers: The Best Wi-Fi Yet Hartland WI
- New 802.11n Routers: The Best Wi-Fi Yet Hudson WI
- New 802.11n Routers: The Best Wi-Fi Yet Janesville WI
- New 802.11n Routers: The Best Wi-Fi Yet Kaukauna WI
- New 802.11n Routers: The Best Wi-Fi Yet Kenosha WI
- New 802.11n Routers: The Best Wi-Fi Yet La Crosse WI
- New 802.11n Routers: The Best Wi-Fi Yet Lake Geneva WI
- New 802.11n Routers: The Best Wi-Fi Yet Madison WI
- New 802.11n Routers: The Best Wi-Fi Yet Manitowoc WI
- New 802.11n Routers: The Best Wi-Fi Yet Marinette WI
- New 802.11n Routers: The Best Wi-Fi Yet Marshfield WI
- New 802.11n Routers: The Best Wi-Fi Yet Menasha WI
- New 802.11n Routers: The Best Wi-Fi Yet Menomonee Falls WI
- New 802.11n Routers: The Best Wi-Fi Yet Menomonie WI
- New 802.11n Routers: The Best Wi-Fi Yet Merrill WI
- New 802.11n Routers: The Best Wi-Fi Yet Middleton WI
- New 802.11n Routers: The Best Wi-Fi Yet Milwaukee WI
- New 802.11n Routers: The Best Wi-Fi Yet Monroe WI
- New 802.11n Routers: The Best Wi-Fi Yet Mosinee WI
- New 802.11n Routers: The Best Wi-Fi Yet Mukwonago WI
- New 802.11n Routers: The Best Wi-Fi Yet Muskego WI
- New 802.11n Routers: The Best Wi-Fi Yet Neenah WI
- New 802.11n Routers: The Best Wi-Fi Yet New Berlin WI
- New 802.11n Routers: The Best Wi-Fi Yet Oak Creek WI
- New 802.11n Routers: The Best Wi-Fi Yet Oconomowoc WI
- New 802.11n Routers: The Best Wi-Fi Yet Onalaska WI
- New 802.11n Routers: The Best Wi-Fi Yet Oshkosh WI
- New 802.11n Routers: The Best Wi-Fi Yet Pewaukee WI
- New 802.11n Routers: The Best Wi-Fi Yet Plymouth WI
- New 802.11n Routers: The Best Wi-Fi Yet Racine WI
- New 802.11n Routers: The Best Wi-Fi Yet Rhinelander WI
- New 802.11n Routers: The Best Wi-Fi Yet Rice Lake WI
- New 802.11n Routers: The Best Wi-Fi Yet River Falls WI
- New 802.11n Routers: The Best Wi-Fi Yet Schofield WI
- New 802.11n Routers: The Best Wi-Fi Yet Shawano WI
- New 802.11n Routers: The Best Wi-Fi Yet Sheboygan WI
- New 802.11n Routers: The Best Wi-Fi Yet South Milwaukee WI
- New 802.11n Routers: The Best Wi-Fi Yet Sparta WI
- New 802.11n Routers: The Best Wi-Fi Yet Stevens Point WI
- New 802.11n Routers: The Best Wi-Fi Yet Stoughton WI
- New 802.11n Routers: The Best Wi-Fi Yet Sturgeon Bay WI
- New 802.11n Routers: The Best Wi-Fi Yet Sun Prairie WI
- New 802.11n Routers: The Best Wi-Fi Yet Superior WI
- New 802.11n Routers: The Best Wi-Fi Yet Sussex WI
- New 802.11n Routers: The Best Wi-Fi Yet Thiensville WI
- New 802.11n Routers: The Best Wi-Fi Yet Two Rivers WI
- New 802.11n Routers: The Best Wi-Fi Yet Waterford WI
- New 802.11n Routers: The Best Wi-Fi Yet Watertown WI
- New 802.11n Routers: The Best Wi-Fi Yet Waukesha WI
- New 802.11n Routers: The Best Wi-Fi Yet Waupaca WI
- New 802.11n Routers: The Best Wi-Fi Yet Wausau WI
- New 802.11n Routers: The Best Wi-Fi Yet West Bend WI
- New 802.11n Routers: The Best Wi-Fi Yet Whitewater WI
- New 802.11n Routers: The Best Wi-Fi Yet Wisconsin Rapids WI
Rate Article
     
Articles Insider

Rss   Delicious   Digg   Add To My Yahoo   Add To My Google   Bookmark   Search Plugin

Topics:
Advertising Entertainment Home Electronics Software
Business Services Family Home Services Technology
Career Fashion Internet Telecommunications
Cars Financial Services Legal Trade Shows
Computer Hardware Franchise Miscellaneous Travel
Construction Health Nightlife Weddings
Education Holidays Online Database World History
Educational Content Home Appliances Real Estate Resources